Comparing candidates and moving them on from Shortlisting
Read the list and comparison views, see who has been reviewed, filter, export and move candidates to the next stage.
Read the list and comparison views, see who has been reviewed, filter, export and move candidates to the next stage.
This is for reviewers, recruiters and hiring managers who work in a job's Shortlisting tab once scores are coming in. A checklist must already be attached to the stage. To score a candidate, see "Scoring a candidate in Shortlisting".
List view and comparison view
The workspace opens in List view. Each row shows the candidate, their Assessment, a Status and a Review button. For scoring checklists the assessment is the averaged total, for example 7.50/10, with a bar. Beside it, "Essential 6.50 · Desirable 1.00" splits that total by the importance label on each criterion. The two numbers are averaged across reviewers like the score, so they add up to it. For ranking checklists the assessment is a count of how many reviewers chose each level. A candidate nobody has scored shows "Not scored".
Where the stage needs several reviewers and they have not all submitted yet, the totals are replaced by "Awaiting scoring". This follows the same rule that blocks a move, and it ignores checklists that are switched off.
The status badge reads Pending (no reviews yet), Ready (a ranking checklist with at least one review, or a scoring total that meets the pass threshold) or Manual (the total is below the threshold, or there is no threshold, so someone has to decide). When the stage has sub-statuses, a dropdown under the badge sets the candidate's sub-status, for example Suitable or Not Suitable. Changing it updates the Pipeline tab too.
The grid icon in the top right switches to Comparison view. Candidates become columns and criteria become rows. Each column heading shows the candidate's name, how many reviews they have (or Pending) and an Evaluate button. The last row is the Total, with the Essential and Desirable split. When the stage has a pass threshold it also shows a tick for candidates who meet it and a cross for those who do not. Sort by score puts the highest totals first and unreviewed candidates last. The grid shows only the candidates on the current page of the list, 25 to a page. A ranking checklist has a single Rank row instead of criteria.
Filters and candidates who have moved on
Use the filter above the list to show All, Reviewed by me or Not reviewed by me. Each option shows a count. On a ranking checklist a Filter by your ranking dropdown also appears, with All rankings, Not yet ranked by me and each ranking level. Selecting all respects the filter.
Candidates who have moved on from the stage stay on the tab. Their row carries a badge reading "Moved to" and the new stage, or "Moved on" if that stage is hidden from you. Once anyone has moved on, a Show candidates toggle appears with All candidates, In this stage and Moved on, each with a count. Moved on candidates cannot be ticked, and their scores open read-only. With none yet, the Moved on view says "No candidates have moved on from this stage yet."
Reviewers, progress and what you can see
A stage can have Assigned reviewers and a Minimum reviewers required. Only submissions from assigned reviewers count towards the minimum. With no minimum set, every assigned reviewer must submit. A stage with no assigned reviewers has no completion requirement.
On the Pipeline tab, candidates in a screening stage are grouped under a badge that tracks progress: Unstarted (no evaluations yet), Partially Complete (fewer evaluations than the minimum) and Complete (the minimum has been reached, or one evaluation if no minimum is set). The first stage in the pipeline, usually Applied, does not show this badge.
What you see of other reviewers depends on your role and the stage's Reviewer Scoping and Blind Scoring settings. The averages, the Assessment column, the Status badge and the review counts are all worked out from the evaluations you are allowed to see, so for a reviewer limited to their own scores, "Ready" reflects their evaluation alone. "Shortlisting candidates" sets out who sees which scores.
Pass threshold and moving candidates on
For a scoring checklist the total is each criterion's average across reviewers, added together. It meets the pass threshold when it is equal to or higher than the number set. Moving a candidate forward from the stage is refused in two situations:
- Not enough assigned reviewers have submitted. The message names the checklist and the count, for example "Shortlisting review is incomplete for: Sales checklist (1/2)". This is checked first.
- The total is below the pass threshold. You see Shortlisting Threshold Not Met. A candidate with no evaluations at all is not stopped by the threshold.
Both checks count every reviewer's evaluation, even when you can only see your own. Moving a candidate backwards is never blocked.
Admin, HR and the job's recruiters can move candidates, and so can others if your organisation allows it. If you cannot, the buttons are greyed out and hovering explains that only admins, HR and this job's recruiter can move, reject or withdraw candidates.
- Tick the candidates in List view. The tick box in the table header selects everyone on the page when nothing is ticked, and clears the selection if any row is ticked. When a whole page is ticked and more candidates match, a link such as "Select all 40 matching candidates" appears.
- In the bar that appears, choose a stage and select Move to Stage.
- Check the confirmation. It is headed "Move 3 candidates?" and lists "Moving from:" each stage with its count, then "Moving to:" the target stage. It shows counts and stages only, never names, so it is safe on blind and confidential jobs.
- Select the confirm button, which reads "Move 3 candidates".
The same bar has Reject Selected and Clear. For rejecting and withdrawing, see "Rejecting candidates".
Exporting results and seeing scores elsewhere
Use Export in the list toolbar to download the results as Export as CSV or Export as Excel. The last column is Reference Number. Blind Scoring anonymises reviewer names in the export.
On a candidate's Notes & Feedback tab, Shortlisting scores and Interview scores sections show the scores for the selected application together. Blind scoring rules still apply.