How interview feedback scores and thresholds are worked out
What each figure in the Feedback Summary means, and what a missed pass threshold does when you move a candidate.
What each figure in the Feedback Summary means, and what a missed pass threshold does when you move a candidate.
This is for anyone who can open an interview's feedback screen: System Admin and HR users, and recruiters, hiring managers and interviewers connected to the candidate. The Feedback Summary sits below your own scorecard and combines everyone's submissions for the application. On a job with blind scoring, people other than System Admin and HR users see only Total Reviewers.
Feedback Summary
The panel can contain the following, from top to bottom.
- Total Reviewers: the number of submissions recorded. It is shown even when it is zero.
- Overall Score: one number to one decimal place, followed by a Meets threshold or Does not meet threshold badge when the stage has a pass threshold.
- Respondents: how many different people have submitted, shown as "2 / 3" against the minimum the stage asks for, with a Minimum respondents met or Minimum respondents not met badge.
- Average Scores: one line per rating question, with stars and the average to one decimal place.
- Recommendations: a badge per recommendation given, with the number of reviewers who chose it, for example "Yes (2)".
How the scores are calculated
Only rating questions count. Yes/no switches and free text are ignored by every calculation.
- Each average under Average Scores is the mean of all reviewers' ratings for that question, rounded to one decimal place. The stars are rounded to the nearest whole star.
- When a reviewer submits, Recruit works out their own overall score: the average of their ratings, rounded to a whole number. The Overall Score is then the mean of those whole numbers across reviewers, to one decimal place. Because of the early rounding, it can differ slightly from the mean of the question averages.
- A submission with no rating questions does not affect the Overall Score. If nobody has given any ratings, the row is not shown.
- Rating questions run from 1 up to a maximum set on the feedback form, 5 by default and up to 10. Scores from forms with different maximums are added together as they are, not converted to a common scale.
When the threshold and respondent badges appear
The pass threshold and minimum respondents are set per stage, in the job's pipeline, on an Interview stage next to the feedback form (Pass Threshold and Minimum Respondents). "Choosing the feedback form for an interview stage" covers where to set them.
The summary shows the badges only when all the feedback so far comes from one stage and that stage has the setting. If the candidate has feedback from two interview stages, the averages and the overall score still appear, but the threshold and respondents lines do not.
The threshold is compared with the Overall Score as it stands, so set it on the same scale as the form's ratings. A threshold of 4 on a form scored out of 5 means something very different from 4 on a form scored out of 10. Respondents counts distinct people, so nobody is counted twice.
How thresholds affect moving a candidate
A missed threshold never blocks a move. When you move a candidate forward out of an Interview stage that has a pass threshold or a minimum number of respondents, the move goes ahead and a warning appears with it:
- "Interview feedback score 3.5 is below the required threshold of 4." This appears when at least one reviewer has submitted and the overall score for that stage is under the threshold.
- "Only 1 of 3 required interview feedback responses have been submitted." This appears when fewer people have submitted than the stage's minimum, including when nobody has.
The numbers shown are the ones for the stage the candidate is leaving. The warnings apply to any forward move, not only a move to an offer.