Building an interview feedback form template
Build the scorecard interviewers complete after an interview, change it safely later, and find the results.
Build the scorecard interviewers complete after an interview, change it safely later, and find the results.
An interview feedback form template is the scorecard an interviewer fills in after meeting a candidate. System Admins and HR users build the templates, and Members can too when a System Admin has allowed it. A template does nothing until it is attached to an interview stage, and a stage with no template gives interviewers no scorecard at all. Attaching a template to a stage, the pass threshold and minimum respondents, and what interviewers see when a stage has no form are covered in the article on choosing the feedback form for an interview stage.
Who can manage templates
System Admin and HR users can open Settings then Feedback Forms and create, edit, duplicate or delete templates. Members cannot, unless a System Admin has switched on Member feedback templates under Template permissions in Settings then Roles & Permissions. With that switched on, a Member can create templates, edit the ones they created and duplicate any template. A Member cannot delete templates or open the Video Interview Questions tab. The article "Letting Members create feedback templates and checklists" covers the setting. Anyone else can choose a template from the stage dropdown when they set up a job, but cannot change what is in it. If you manage a group of companies, a company selector at the top of the page switches company.
The page has three tabs: Shortlisting Checklists, Interview Feedback and Video Interview Questions. They hold separate kinds of template. This article covers the Interview Feedback tab.
Create a template
- Go to Settings then Feedback Forms and open the Interview Feedback tab.
- Select + Add Form at the bottom of the list on the left. The Create Interview Feedback Form window opens.
- Enter a Form Name (up to 200 characters). This is required. Add a Description if you want one (up to 2,000 characters). Interviewers see it above the scorecard.
- The window starts with one blank question. Type the question in the first field (up to 500 characters), choose its Type, and switch Required on or off.
- Select Add Question for each further question. A form can hold up to 100 questions. The bin icon removes a question, except when only one is left.
- Select Create Form. The button stays greyed out until the form has a name and at least one question with text. Any question left blank is discarded.
The new template appears in the list with its question count. To make a variation of an existing template, select it and choose Duplicate. The copy is named after the original with (copy) added, and you can then rename and change it. If the copy fails you see Couldn't copy this form. Please try again. Use the Search forms... box to find a template by name. New organisations are set up with three ready-made templates: General Interview, Technical Deep Dive and Values & Culture. You can edit or delete these like any other.
Question types, rating scales and required questions
- Rating: the interviewer picks a score using stars. Under the question, the number field next to Scale 1 sets the top score. It accepts whole numbers from 1 to 10 and defaults to 5. A value outside that range is corrected automatically.
- Yes / No: a switch that starts on No.
- Text: a free-text box for written comments.
Every scorecard also ends with an Overall Recommendation (Strong No, No, Maybe, Yes or Strong Yes) and an Additional Notes box. These are built in. You cannot add, remove or edit them in a template, and the recommendation is always required.
Questions are required by default. An interviewer cannot submit the scorecard until every required question has an answer, and sees the message Please answer all required questions before submitting. A Yes / No question always has an answer because the switch starts on No, so marking one as required changes nothing in practice.
Edit a template that already has feedback
- Open Settings, Feedback Forms, Interview Feedback and select the template in the list.
- Change the name, description or questions on the right. Add Question adds a new one.
- Select Save. The button is greyed out if the name is empty or no question has text.
A Member can save changes only to a form they created. On any other form they see Only the person who created this form, an Admin or HR can change it. Use Duplicate to make your own copy. and the form is read-only until they duplicate it.
Each stage keeps its own copy of the form as it was when you chose it. Under the questions, a note reads Saving changes the template only. Interview stages already using it keep the questions they were given. After you save, a message confirms Existing interview stages are unchanged. So an edit changes the template in the list and the stages you attach it to from then on. Stages that already use it keep the questions they had, and in-progress scorecards on those stages use that copy.
To give an existing stage the new version, open the job's Pipeline step and choose a form on that stage again. Choosing the same form again does not refresh it. Either duplicate the edited template and choose the copy, or choose None, save, then choose the edited form and save again.
Feedback that has already been submitted does not change. Each submitted scorecard keeps the exact questions and wording the interviewer answered, even if you later rename or remove a question, or delete the template. Feedback submitted before the wording was kept shows the current wording, with a notice saying so.
Delete a template
Only System Admin and HR users can delete a template. Select the bin icon on the template in the list and confirm with Delete. The message reads Are you sure you want to delete this template? This action cannot be undone. Any stage using the template is left with no form, so interviewers on that stage see No feedback form for this stage and cannot submit feedback until an admin or HR user attaches another template. Feedback already submitted is kept.
Where the results appear
Submitted feedback shows on the candidate's Notes & Feedback tab. The tab opens with an Interview scores card: a table for each interview stage with one row per question, one column per reviewer and an Overall row. Where an interviewer's scores are hidden by blind scoring, their column is left out.
The Feedback Summary shows Average Scores for each question, the Recommendations given and the Overall Score. When the stage has a threshold or a minimum set, it also shows a Meets threshold or Does not meet threshold badge, and a respondents count such as 1 / 2. Team Feedback lists each interviewer's scorecard. If blind scoring is on for the job, users who are not admins do not see the scores or the summary.