Skip to content
English
  • There are no suggestions because the search field is empty.

Reviewing and scoring candidates as a hiring manager

How to review candidates in the pipeline, read their profiles and CVs, and score them at a shortlisting stage.

How to review candidates in the pipeline, read their profiles and CVs, and score them at a shortlisting stage.

This is for hiring managers and interviewers who are on a job's team. Scoring needs the job to have a stage with shortlisting switched on, which your recruiter or HR team set up.

Reviewing candidates in the pipeline

The Pipeline tab lists candidates by stage. Switch between List and Kanban with the buttons at the top. Type in Search candidates... to find someone, and use Filters to add Source, Tag, From and To application dates, Sub-status and, in the list view, Stage. Clear Filters resets them. Stages that are set to be hidden from your role do not appear.

Select a candidate to open the review panel. It shows their documents on one side and their details on the other, with Previous candidate and Next candidate arrows so you can work through the whole stage. Choose View full profile for everything held on the candidate.

Candidate profiles and CVs

A profile opens on the Overview tab, which holds contact details, an application summary, the CV, cover letter, work history, education and the answers the candidate gave on the application form. The other tabs you will use are Offers, Timeline (the candidate's activity history) and Notes & Feedback.

A profile shows one application at a time. If the candidate has applied to more than one job, a Switch application drop-down at the top of the profile lets you choose which one you are looking at. Applications a candidate has started but not submitted, and disqualified applications, are visible to Admin and HR only. Notes, offers and feedback on the profile all follow the application you have selected. If you have typed a note you have not added and you switch, Recruit asks "Discard unsaved changes?".

To read the CV, open the Documents section and select View CV. Hide CV closes it and Download saves the file. If the file is a type that cannot be previewed, download it instead. An uploaded cover letter opens the same way, and Hide closes it. Your Admin can switch off CV access for Members across the organisation. When that is on, the CV section shows "No document uploaded." and you cannot preview or download CVs.

In the application responses, Download application is a menu with Shortlisting version and Interview version. A Full version appears for Admin and HR only.

Scoring in Shortlisting

Open the job and select the Shortlisting tab. If more than one stage has shortlisting switched on, choose the stage under Shortlisting stage. The panel shows the checklist in use, whether the stage uses Scoring or Ranking, and how many reviewers are required. Candidates are listed with their Assessment and Status. Filter by All, Reviewed by me or Not reviewed by me, each with a count. Comparison view lays candidates side by side and List view switches back.

  1. Select Review on a candidate. The CV, cover letter and application responses show on the left and the evaluation form on the right.
  2. For a Scoring stage, enter a number for each criterion, from 0 up to that criterion's maximum. For a Ranking stage, pick a level from the Rank list.
  3. Add Notes if you want to.
  4. Select Submit & Next to move on to the next candidate (shown while more candidates remain), or Submit & Close. You see "Evaluation submitted successfully".

Open the candidate again later to change your evaluation and resubmit. Under the form, Other Reviewers shows the group's totals and each reviewer's evaluation, subject to the blind scoring rules. Export downloads the stage results as CSV or Excel, and hidden identities stay hidden in the file.

Scores are split into two lines, shown as "Essential 7.25 · Desirable 3.25" with two decimal places. You see this on the list, the comparison view and each reviewer's assessment. Until all the reviewers the stage requires have finished, the candidate shows "Awaiting scoring" instead.

Candidates who have moved on from the stage stay in the list with a badge such as "Moved to" followed by the new stage, or "Moved on". Once anyone has moved on, a Show candidates control appears with All candidates, In this stage and Moved on, each with a count. Scores for moved-on candidates are read-only: "This candidate has moved on from this stage. Scores are read-only."

On a Ranking stage there is also a Filter by your ranking list with All rankings, Not yet ranked by me and each rank level.

Notes, interview feedback and offers

On the candidate's Notes & Feedback tab, Shortlisting scores and Interview scores sections show the scores for the application you have selected. If there are none you can see, you read "No shortlisting scores are visible for this application." or "No interview scores are visible for this application." Blind scoring still applies.

For notes, including mentions and pinning, see "Adding notes to a candidate". For interview feedback, open Interviews in the menu and see "Submitting interview feedback". Interviewers also receive a calendar invite with the Interview booked email.

The Offers tab has an Offer History listing the offers for the selected application, with salary, status (Draft, Sent, Accepted, Declined, Expired, Superseded or Withdrawn), start date, sent and response dates, and any decline reason. If there are none you see "No offers for this application yet." Creating, withdrawing and downloading signed contracts is done by Admin and HR. If your organisation lets you send draft offers, see "Reviewing and sending a draft offer as a Hiring Manager".