Submitting interview feedback
Complete the scorecard after an interview, choose your overall recommendation and submit it against the candidate.
Complete the scorecard after an interview, choose your overall recommendation and submit it against the candidate.
After an interview, each interviewer completes a scorecard and gives an overall recommendation. The feedback is recorded against the candidate and the interview stage, and the rest of the hiring team can read it. Once submitted it cannot be changed.
Who can submit and what must be in place
System Admin and HR users can submit feedback on any interview. Everyone else can submit only if one of these applies to them for that candidate and stage:
- They have been assigned to interview the candidate.
- They are in the interviewer pool of the stage.
- They are an interviewer or host on an event the candidate has been booked into for that stage.
If none of these applies, submitting fails with the message "You are not assigned to interview this candidate". Ask a System Admin, an HR user or the job's recruiter to add you. Agency users cannot open the Interviews page. Each person can submit once per candidate and stage. A second attempt is refused with "Feedback already submitted for this application and stage".
The stage the candidate is in must have a feedback form applied to it, as described in "Choosing the feedback form for an interview stage". The form itself is built under Settings > Job Setup > Feedback Forms, as described in "Building an interview feedback form template". If the stage has no form, the feedback screen shows No feedback form for this stage and nothing can be submitted. Tell the recruiter or an administrator, who can attach a form to the stage.
Feedback is tied to the candidate's pipeline stage, so it is collected only for interview stages that have a feedback form. Ad hoc interviews have no scorecard and never appear in Feedback Required.
Find the interview and complete the scorecard
- Open Interviews from the main navigation.
- Look in the Feedback Required list. The filters above the lists (Job, Interviewer, Location and the date range) help if the list is long.
- Select Submit Feedback on the row for the candidate. You can also open the feedback screen by selecting an interview in the calendar at the top of the page.
- Read the description at the top of the Scorecard, if there is one. Whoever built the form writes it, and it usually says what the interview should cover.
- Answer each question. There are three types:
- Rating: select a star. The row runs from 1 star up to the maximum set on the form, which is 5 by default and can be up to 10. The star you select is your score.
- Yes / No: a switch that starts on No. Leave it as it is if the answer is no.
- Text: a box for written comments.
- Under Overall Recommendation, choose Strong No, No, Maybe, Yes or Strong Yes. The question asked is whether you would recommend hiring this candidate. This is always required.
- Add anything else in Additional Notes. This box is optional.
- Select Submit Feedback.
Questions marked with a red asterisk are required. If you submit with a required question unanswered, you see Please answer all required questions before submitting. If you have not chosen a recommendation, you see Please select an overall recommendation. Nothing is saved until both are sorted out.
There is no draft save. If you select Cancel, use the back arrow or close the page before submitting, your answers are lost. Finish the scorecard in one sitting.
What happens when you submit
- A Feedback Submitted! message appears briefly, and you are taken to the Notes & Feedback tab for that application, where your entry is listed straight away. If the candidate cannot be identified, you are taken back to the Interviews page instead.
- The tab opens with an Interview scores card: a table for each interview stage, with one row per question, one column per reviewer and an Overall row.
- The interview leaves your Feedback Required list and appears under Completed Interviews.
- Recruiters on the job's team receive an email saying that interview feedback has been submitted for the application. It does not contain your answers. An email goes out for every submission, not only when the last interviewer has finished, and a recruiter can switch it off with the Interview feedback completed option in their notification settings.
- Your answers count towards the Feedback Summary. "Viewing team feedback and the feedback summary" explains how the scores are combined and who can see what.
Moving the candidate on does not wait for feedback. If the stage has a pass threshold or a minimum number of respondents that has not been met, you get a warning when moving the candidate forward, but the move still goes ahead.
To read your own feedback later, open Interviews, find the interview under Completed Interviews and select View Feedback. The page opens with the heading Feedback Submitted, your recommendation as a badge beside the stage name, and every answer locked. The questions appear as they were when you answered them, so later changes to the form do not alter your submission. Feedback from before this copy was kept shows the note "Original question wording unavailable".
Submitted feedback cannot be edited or withdrawn by the interviewer. If you gave the wrong recommendation or missed a point, speak to the recruiter running the job.
Blind scoring and hidden candidates
Two job settings change what you see on this screen. With blind scoring on, you still see your own scorecard in full, but other reviewers appear only as "Reviewer 1", "Reviewer 2" and so on, and the summary is reduced. With confidential shortlisting on, the candidate can appear as "Candidate" followed by a reference number until their identity is revealed. Neither setting stops you submitting feedback. Both are covered in "Blind scoring and confidential shortlisting".
If an interview is not in your list
- An interview appears in Feedback Required only after its start time has passed, and only while the candidate is still in that interview stage and has not been rejected or withdrawn. The interview must also have a booked time, and the stage must have a feedback form.
- You must be assigned to the candidate, in the stage's interviewer pool, or on the event.
- No feedback form for this stage: no form has been attached to the stage. Tell the recruiter or an administrator.
"The interviews page" explains the lists and filters in full.