Building shortlisting checklists
How to create, edit, copy, archive and delete the scoring or ranking checklists your reviewers use to shortlist candidates.
How to create, edit, copy, archive and delete the scoring or ranking checklists your reviewers use to shortlist candidates.
A shortlisting checklist is the set of criteria your reviewers use to assess candidates at a screening stage. You build it once under Settings, then attach it to the screening stages of each job. Interview stages do not use checklists: they use feedback forms (see Interview feedback form templates). Attaching a checklist to a job is covered in Attaching a checklist to a job stage.
Who can create and edit checklists
Admin and HR users can create, edit, duplicate, archive and delete any checklist. An Admin can also let Members author checklists. Go to Settings, Roles & Permissions, and in the Template permissions group switch on Allow Members to create and edit their own feedback templates under Member feedback templates. Only administrators can change this setting.
With it on, a Member can create shortlisting checklists and interview feedback forms, edit the ones they created, and copy existing ones with Duplicate. They cannot archive or delete templates, and they cannot change video interview templates. If a Member opens a checklist someone else created, it is read only and says "Only the person who created this checklist, an Admin or HR can change it. Use Duplicate to make your own copy." History, archiving and deleting stay with Admin and HR.
Create a checklist
- Go to Settings > Feedback Forms and stay on the Shortlisting Checklists tab.
- Select + Add Checklist under the list on the left.
- Enter a Checklist Name (required, up to 255 characters).
- Add a Description if you want reviewers to see guidance on when to use it (up to 2,000 characters).
- Choose the Checklist Type: Scoring or Ranking.
- Select New Checklist. It is created with starter content, and opens in the Edit panel on the right.
- Change the criteria or ranking levels, then select Save.
If you manage a group of organisations, choose the company from the selector at the top right of the page first. Checklists belong to one company.
Scoring and ranking checklists
In a scoring checklist, reviewers give each criterion a number and Recruit adds them up. A new scoring checklist starts with two criteria, Role fit and Experience quality, each worth 5 and marked Essential. Use Add Criterion to add more. Each criterion has:
- Criterion: the wording reviewers see, up to 500 characters. It cannot be blank.
- Importance: Essential or Desirable. It is a label shown next to the criterion when reviewers score. It does not weight the score and it does not stop a candidate progressing. It does split the total shown on the Shortlisting tab into an Essential figure and a Desirable figure, for example "Essential 7.00 · Desirable 3.00".
- Max Score: a whole number from 1 to 10. Reviewers cannot enter more than this.
A scoring checklist needs at least one criterion, so the bin icon is disabled on the last one.
In a ranking checklist, reviewers pick one level from a list instead of entering numbers. A new ranking checklist starts with Strong Yes, Yes, Maybe and No. Rename them, or use Add Level to add your own. You need at least two levels, and each label must be filled in. Ranking checklists have no total score, so they cannot have a pass threshold or blind scoring.
Change, copy, archive or delete a checklist
Select a checklist on the left to edit it. The left list is sorted A to Z, can be searched by name, and shows each checklist's criteria count (or "Ranking checklist") and how many jobs use it. The job count only includes jobs you are allowed to see, and it may not be shown at all.
- Changing the Checklist Type discards the current criteria or levels when you save.
- Duplicate creates a copy called "name (Copy)" with the same type, criteria and max scores. The Importance setting is not copied: every criterion in the copy is Essential until you change it.
- Archive hides a checklist from the list and stops it being attached to more stages. Turn on Show archived to find it again, and select Unarchive to bring it back. Stages already using it keep working.
- The bin icon deletes a checklist. It cannot be undone, and a checklist that is still attached to a stage cannot be deleted. Archive it instead.
- History lists each change (created, updated, archived and so on) with the date.
Editing a checklist does not change jobs that already use it. See Updating jobs after a checklist changes.
If Save is greyed out
A criterion or ranking level is blank. The field shows "Criterion text is required" or "Ranking level label is required". Fill it in or remove the row.