Skip to content
English
  • There are no suggestions because the search field is empty.

Viewing team feedback and the feedback summary

Where to find each interviewer's scorecard and the team's feedback for a candidate, and who can see what.

Where to find each interviewer's scorecard and the team's feedback for a candidate, and who can see what.

Feedback from interviews shows up in two places: the candidate's Notes & Feedback tab, and the feedback screen for an individual interview. The tab gives a quick view of scores and recommendations. The feedback screen gives the full scorecard, the Feedback Summary and the Team Feedback panel. To fill in and submit a scorecard, see "Submitting interview feedback".

The Notes and Feedback tab

Open a candidate and select the Notes & Feedback tab. Everything on it follows the application selected at the top of the profile. To see feedback on another job, switch application.

The tab opens with an Interview scores card. For each interview stage with scored feedback it shows a table with one row per question and one column per reviewer, headed by the reviewer's name. Each cell shows the score against the top of the scale, for example 4 / 5, or a dash where that reviewer gave no score. An Overall row shows each reviewer's overall score. If no application is selected the card reads Select an application to see its interview scores. If nothing is visible to you it reads No interview scores are visible for this application. Feedback given under blind scoring carries no scores, so it does not appear in this card.

Below it is the Interview Feedback card, headed by a count such as "3 feedback entries". It lists the newest first. Each entry shows:

  • The interviewer's name, or "Anonymous interviewer" if the name is not available.
  • Their recommendation as a badge: Strong hire, Hire, Maybe, No hire or Strong no hire. These are the five choices interviewers pick from (Strong Yes to Strong No), worded for hiring.
  • Any additional notes they wrote.
  • The date, the job title and the stage, on one line underneath.

The entries are shown to System Admin and HR users only. Anyone else sees the card with the message "Interview feedback is visible to recruiters and hiring managers only" and no entries, even if they are a recruiter or hiring manager on the job. If you are in that position, use the feedback screen. When there is nothing yet, the card says No interview feedback yet for this application. If the list cannot load, the card shows a retry line.

The feedback screen for one interview

From the Interviews page, select Submit Feedback on a row in Feedback Required, or View Feedback on a row in Completed Interviews. Selecting an interview in the calendar opens the same screen. "The interviews page" explains the lists.

The screen has three parts, top to bottom:

  1. Your own scorecard. Before you submit it is a form. Afterwards the heading changes to Feedback Submitted, your recommendation shows as a badge next to the stage name, and every answer is read-only. Submitted feedback cannot be edited. Leaving the form without submitting saves nothing.
  2. Feedback Summary, the combined picture from everyone who has submitted. "How interview feedback scores and thresholds are worked out" explains each figure.
  3. Team Feedback, each reviewer's individual submission.

Both panels cover all feedback recorded against that application, not only the stage you opened. If a stage has no feedback form, the scorecard area reads "No feedback form for this stage" and nothing can be submitted until someone applies a form to the stage.

Team Feedback

This panel lists every submission for the application, with Total Reviewers in the top corner. If nothing has been submitted it says "No feedback submitted yet." Each submission is a card with:

  • The reviewer's name and their Overall Recommendation as a coloured badge.
  • Their rating answers as stars, labelled with the question.
  • Their yes/no and written answers, labelled with the question.
  • Their Additional Notes.

Each submission keeps the questions exactly as the reviewer saw them. If someone later renames a question, removes it, changes the form or deletes the form, earlier scorecards do not change. Feedback from before this copy was kept has no saved wording, so its answers are labelled with the current questions and carry the note "Original question wording unavailable". The question may have been reworded since, so read those labels with care.

Who can see other reviewers' feedback

The Feedback Summary and Team Feedback panels are open to:

  • System Admin and HR users, for any application. HR users with restricted location access still only reach jobs in their locations.
  • Other users who are a recruiter or hiring manager on the job, who have been assigned to interview that candidate, or who are in the interviewer pool of the candidate's current stage.

Anyone else gets an "Application not found" error if they try to open the screen. Agency users cannot open the Interviews page at all.

What blind scoring and confidential shortlisting change

Blind scoring is a switch on the job, under its Settings tab as Blind Scoring. Organisations can turn it on for new jobs by default under Settings then Shortlisting Defaults. Once a job is approved or live, only System Admin and HR users see the switch. System Admin and HR users see everything as normal. Everyone else sees a reduced view:

  • Feedback Summary shows only Total Reviewers. The overall score, averages, recommendations, threshold and respondent lines are withheld.
  • Team Feedback shows "Reviewer 1", "Reviewer 2" and so on instead of names. Each card keeps the recommendation and any yes/no answers. Ratings, written answers, notes and submission dates are removed.
  • Your own submission, shown in the scorecard at the top, is not masked.

Confidential shortlisting hides the candidate rather than the reviewers. Where someone is not allowed to see who the candidate is, the Interviews page lists show "Candidate" followed by the application's reference number instead of a name. This applies to hiring managers and interviewers, to recruiters until the application is revealed, and to System Admin and HR users who sit on the hiring team of that job. Identities are revealed when the application reaches the job's Auto-Reveal Stage, or when someone uses Reveal Identity. Feedback is recorded and counted as normal throughout.

Related articles